1-805-484-2992

Quotes - Sizing - Sales

Replacement Sizing Guide

Sizing From Today's Process, Not the Old Nameplate

Overview

If the old unit's data plate is gone, illegible, or from a discontinued line, your process numbers get you to a rating just as reliably.

When a model match isn't available - the nameplate is gone, the brand is discontinued, or the unit predates readily available spec data - sizing from your actual current process is just as accurate as matching an old model number, and it has one real advantage: it reflects your process today rather than whatever it needed when the original unit was installed, which may have changed.

The inputs are the same ones covered in How to Size a Glycol Chiller under Sizing & Selection Guides - heat load, target leaving fluid temperature, and indoor-vs-outdoor installation. If you can measure or estimate those directly from your current operation, you don't need the old unit's spec sheet at all.

Send us what you have - even a rough sense of tank volume, process type, and how the old chiller performed (comfortably, marginally, or struggling) - and we can work toward a sizing recommendation from there, filling in the gaps with the same engineering approach we'd use for a brand-new installation.

  • Sizing from current process reflects today's actual load, not whatever the original install needed
  • Same core inputs as any sizing: heat load, target leaving fluid temperature, indoor vs. outdoor
  • Even partial information (tank volume, process type, how the old unit performed) is a usable starting point

Size to the worst-case load, not the faded nameplate.

How the old unit held setpoint through the hardest part of the year says more than its badge. Size to the fastest cooldown you run, with a real match to that peak instead of a cautious oversize.

Estimating Load Without a Nameplate

Start with what the old unit actually did, not what its badge said. A chiller that comfortably held setpoint through the worst part of the year was almost certainly sized with margin above the true peak load - a struggling unit was likely undersized, marginal, or has lost capacity with age. Either read is more useful for sizing a replacement than a faded tonnage number.

The most common mistake here is sizing off an average operating condition instead of the worst-case one. A tank that's cooled twice a day needs capacity for the fastest cooldown you actually run, not the slower ones - undersizing on the peak is the single most common reason a "correctly sized" replacement still falls short.

Oversizing has its own cost, even though it feels like the safer error. A packaged unit running well below its rated load cycles more often and spends more time at inefficient part-load operation, which shows up as higher energy cost and more wear on the compressor over the unit's life than a properly matched unit would carry. The goal is a real match to the peak, not a large margin added out of caution.

What We Need From You

  • Tank or vessel volume, or process flow rate
  • Target leaving fluid temperture for the process
  • Ambient conditions and indoor/outdoor installation
  • How the old unit performed - comfortably, marginally, or struggling

TYPICAL STARTING POINTS BY DUTY

Duty Type Typical Leaving Fluid Temp Typical Install
Brewery / distillery fermentation 25-30°F Portable or small packaged, indoor or outdoor
Dairy / food & beverage process 28-38°F Portable through packaged central
General industrial process cooling 40-55°F Portable through packaged central, indoor or outdoor
Comfort-adjacent / equipment cooling 45-65°F Packaged central, typically outdoor

These are starting points to sanity-check your numbers against, not a substitute for sizing to your actual load.
Call and talk it through with an engineer: 1-805-484-2992.

Sizing a Replacement Without the Old Nameplate

Work out the heat removed, then divide by the hours it takes. Each gallon of water gives up about 8.33 BTU per degree, which, times 60 minutes, is the 500 in the water formula. A 20 bbl batch is 620 gallons; pulling it down 30°F removes about 155,000 BTU, and doing that in 2 hours is roughly 77,500 BTU/hr, or 6.5 tons. Add the heat the tank and process keep generating during the pull-down, and use the fastest cooldown you actually run. If the old chiller took 3 hours on the same batch and you now need 2, the load is 50 percent higher than what it was delivering, which is exactly the gap a replacement sized off the old badge would miss.

That the daytime load, or the daytime air on the condenser, is beyond what the unit can deliver, and the replacement has to be sized for the afternoon. Overnight the process is often lighter and an air-cooled unit sees cooler air, so a marginal chiller looks fine at 3 a.m. and slips by mid-afternoon. Note when the setpoint starts to drift, how far it goes and the outdoor temperature at the time. Those three readings point to the peak hour that sets the size.

The colder one, for the whole load, if a single loop and a single chiller carry both. A unit running at 28°F delivers less than it would at 45°F, so sizing the combined tons at the warmer duty is the common error, and it shows up as a cold-side loop that never quite reaches setpoint. The table shows how far apart such duties sit, with brewery and distillery fermentation in the mid to high 20s and equipment cooling in the mid 40s and up. Where the warm load is large, moving it onto its own loop or zone can shrink the rating needed at the cold set point. Send the load for each duty seperately.

Roughly, on a single-step unit, and only if you know its capacity at your set point. A chiller good for 20 tons at that temperature that runs 45 minutes of every hour at peak is carrying about 15 tons. A unit that never cycles off at peak tells you less: only that the load is at or above what it can deliver, so the true peak may be higher still. On staged units, the controller's stage log does the same job. Pair the run-time estimate with one flow and temperature reading, and the two together give a figure worth sizing from.

Quote Request Form:

Questions?

1-805-484-2992

Quotes - Sizing - Sales